Triumph in court for UK asbestos victims

Acorn_Lower Service-23

A landmark ruling in the Court of Appeal may help asbestos victims obtain compensation. Graham Dring, acting on behalf of the Asbestos Victims Support Groups Forum, led a challenge against one of the world’s largest manufacturers and suppliers of asbestos products, Cape Intermediate Holdings.

The Appeal Court ruling is a significant step towards establishing the true extent of industry knowledge about the dangers of asbestos, and whether employers were negligent at the time.

Compensation for asbestos victims

Cape was first established in 1893 and became a leading supplier of asbestos products to the UK and Europe, also establishing factories and manufacturing facilities around the UK. They were a hugely influential presence in the asbestos industry, but litigation against the company continues today.

One asbestos victim from County Durham, who brought a compensation claim against Cape, lived opposite one of their asbestos factories. She reportedly played with pieces of asbestos left lying around and suffered mesothelioma as a result of continued exposure.

Awareness of asbestos dangers

The recent ruling in the Court of Appeal was the result of a challenge to Cape’s intention to destroy documents from the case of another asbestos victim – documents that disclosed their awareness of the dangers of asbestos, and the impact their products had on employee health.

Before we look at this case and the implications of its outcome, however, let’s first consider some of the background issues affecting asbestos victims in their attempts to secure compensation through the courts.

Asbestos victims and the battle to obtain justice

One of the main issues faced by asbestos victims is the fact that their initial exposure commonly took place decades previously. It can take many years for asbestos disease to manifest, and it’s often the case that employers closed down during the intervening years.

In these cases, the insurer that provided employer liability insurance can be a route to compensation, but it is not always possible to trace them. Given the timescale involved, there may be little documentation available, especially if the employer no longer exists.

New hope for asbestos victims and their families

Following the Court of Appeal ruling, key documents are now in the public domain that could shed light on how aware Cape Intermediate Holdings, and the Factory Inspectorate charged with regulating the industry, were of the dangers of asbestos.

Mr Dring, spoke on behalf of the Asbestos Victims Support Groups Forum, commenting on the hope provided to asbestos victims around the world as a result of the ruling,

“The Court of Appeal judgment should provide access to a significant amount of documents, which Cape intermediate Holdings (Cape) have refused to disclose: documents which may assist mesothelioma sufferers and their families to claim compensation, and which may throw light on the way early knowledge of the dangers of asbestos was hidden from the public.”¹

If you would like more information on asbestos and asbestos regulations, or you are worried about asbestos due diligence and how to manage an asbestos project, please contact one of our expert consultants at Acorn Analytical Services.

Neil Munro

I work in a dual role at Acorn Analytical Services focused primarily on growing and leading the business from our Northampton office base. My focus is on overseeing all sales, marketing and financial activities from Northampton. I assist clients with high-level asbestos management strategies and training. Together with Ian Stone I host our weekly podcast – Asbestos Knowledge Empire and I'm Co-author of Asbestos The Dark Arts and Fear and Loathing of Health and Safety.

Need Help? Request a Call Back

Request a call back from one of our expert Asbestos Consultants who will help you identify what you need

More Asbestos Articles

WP 6441 Original 39554 scaled e1606141093410

Celebrate Your Unique Talent

Did you know every year November 24th is observed as Celebrate Your Unique Talent Day? No matter how unique or different your talent is, today is the day that you are encouraged to share it with others. Here at Acorn we aren’t shy about our talent. We are the leading experts when it comes to …

Read MoreCelebrate Your Unique Talent

JG Brum Small

Acorn Opens New Birmingham office!

We have some exciting news… We have expanded with the opening of a new Birmingham office! The new office is located on Bristol Road South and will be led by Joe Gore (pictured) and staffed by people from the Birmingham area. Not only will this new office help us to better service our existing clients …

Read MoreAcorn Opens New Birmingham office!

boiler room e1604325326231

Specifications for Asbestos Removal Works – What’s the Point?

Why do we need specifications for removing asbestos? Surely, asbestos removal is just asbestos removal? The truth is there are a million different ways to do asbestos removal. There are different ways to approach projects. The purpose of the specification is to get the clients the right end result. For example, if you were having …

Read MoreSpecifications for Asbestos Removal Works – What’s the Point?

Acorn Jan 2020 Low Res 14 e1604324375354

Asbestos Material Risk Assessments and Priority Risk Assessments

There are two types of assessments, material risk assessment and priority risk assessments. Together they will show you the total risk and help you manage it. What is a material risk assessment? The material risk assessment is carried out by an asbestos surveyor on site and looks at the risk of the asbestos product releasing …

Read MoreAsbestos Material Risk Assessments and Priority Risk Assessments

Regulation 5 e1604323415767

Regulation 5 – what you need to know

Regulation 5 of the Control of Asbestos Regulations relates to the identification of the presence of asbestos. Under regulation 5, it puts the responsibility on the employer to identify asbestos before any building or demolition works are carried out. It covers the non-domestic market and the domestic market. When we are doing a project in …

Read MoreRegulation 5 – what you need to know

WP 6556 Original 39589 Medium e1601897882134

Asbestos spray coatings and problems with its removal

In this blog, we’ll examine asbestos spray coatings and some of the problems you can face when it is being removed. Asbestos spray coatings were phased out in the mid-1970s, so it’s old now and deteriorating. They have a very high asbestos content. It was mixed with Portland cement binder, to stick asbestos fibres together. …

Read MoreAsbestos spray coatings and problems with its removal

Licences blog pic sml

How do you get the right asbestos contractor?

It is so important that you get competent asbestos contractors to carry out asbestos removal works. Asbestos Contractors fall into two categories: non-licensed and licensed. Licensed contractors receive a licence from the HSE to work with licensable asbestos materials. You need a licence if you are going to work on the higher risk materials such …

Read MoreHow do you get the right asbestos contractor?

Acorn School Site 47 e1601897304536

Asbestos Reinspections

In this blog we will look at asbestos reinspections and how they differ from a survey. Usually, reinspections follow on from some sort of survey – you should have an existing asbestos register from a management survey or a refurbishment survey. Your existing asbestos information – outlining where the asbestos is and what condition it …

Read MoreAsbestos Reinspections

work 731198 1920

What you need to know about asbestos databases

Asbestos databases are sometimes called portals and are an electronic place where your asbestos information and Health & Safety information is held and stored on an online system. Lots of things are going into the Cloud and that is why we have moved in that direction. In the past, Asbestos survey reports were on paper …

Read MoreWhat you need to know about asbestos databases

Blog 4 - house Acorn Jan 2020 Low Res-96

Common asbestos materials in domestic properties

When people think about asbestos, they often associate it with larger buildings such as warehouses, schools, hospitals and factories. Often, people do not think about asbestos when it comes to homes, but asbestos was heavily used in parts of the domestic market and used on large scales within local authority homes. In this blog, we …

Read MoreCommon asbestos materials in domestic properties