Asbestos management inquiry held by Government

The Government’s Work and Pensions Committee has been carrying out an inquiry into the HSE's approach to asbestos management

Over the past few months, the Government’s Work and Pensions Committee has been carrying out an inquiry into the approach of the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) to asbestos management in buildings.

There are six million tonnes of asbestos in the UK, most of which can be found in more than 1.5 million buildings across our public estate, including our hospitals and schools. This means many people are still exposed to the potential dangers of asbestos on a daily basis.

Consequently, despite a complete ban on the use of asbestos in 1999, the UK’s hidden legacy of asbestos means the dangerous substance remains the UK’s largest single cause of work-related deaths.

More than 5,000 people die every year from diseases linked to asbestos, including mesothelioma, lung cancer and asbestosis.

Why is the HSE’s approach to asbestos management being looked at now?

The Committee first raised concerns about the UK’s policy on asbestos management with the Government in 2020 following a report by the independent think tank Respublica.

The report concluded that while attempts to manage asbestos’ potential harm have been made, there remained clear and present dangers to the population from asbestos in-situ.

It said due to the sheer volume of asbestos in our built environment the task of managing this material demands a strong response from government but it found this to be ‘absent in the current health and safety regime’.

Respublica said understanding the true scale of the problem is difficult because there is no central database that identifies which buildings contain which type of asbestos, where – within these structures – asbestos is present, and what condition it is in.

It highlighted the current health and safety regime is based on the assumption that asbestos is safe unless disturbed. Asbestos management in-situ, rather than systematic phased removal, is therefore the preferred policy position, with responsibility falling on individual ‘duty holders’ to ensure health and safety regulations are complied with.

It added where asbestos in-situ is disturbed, there is a requirement to monitor for asbestos fibres released into the air. However, it found the UK’s air monitoring standards fall below those of other European countries, whose testing methods are up to one hundred times more sensitive in detecting dangerous airborne particles.

What is the Government hoping to learn about the HSE’s approach to asbestos management?

After the Committee raised its concerns about the UK’s asbestos management policy, the Minister for Employment confirmed the HSE would be reviewing the effectiveness of the regulations for managing asbestos.

The Committee’s inquiry is examining the current risks posed by asbestos in the workplace, the actions taken by the HSE to mitigate them and how the UK’s approach compares to those taken in other countries.

So far, the Committee has held three sessions where it has invited leading experts to give evidence.

It began by interviewing safety campaigners, representatives from charities and support groups and French, German and Dutch experts in asbestos management.

It later interviewed epidemiologists, occupational hygiene experts and representatives from the Institution of Occupational Safety and Health and from asbestos industry associations such as the UK Asbestos Training Association (UKATA).

In the past few days, it held its final session where it interviewed the Minister of State for Disabled People, Work and Health Chloe Smith MP as well as the HSE’s chief executive and chief scientific officer.

The results of the inquiry will feed into the executive’s review and have yet to be published.

What can we do to improve asbestos management?

At Acorn we’re delighted this inquiry is taking place because despite the introduction of the Control of Asbestos at Work Regulations 2002 very little has changed in people’s attitudes towards asbestos in the past two decades.

As a result, some companies do a good job of managing their asbestos but week in week out we see the same issues we were seeing in 2002.

We still go to premises that have never had an asbestos management survey and don’t have an asbestos register – it’s as if they’re unaware of the past 20 years.

Environmental health officers go to premises for things like cleanliness and give premises hygiene ratings and we believe the same thing should happen with asbestos. There should be health and safety ratings for asbestos for businesses.

We’ve seen the HSE can do it. During Covid-19 they did lots of unannounced visits to premises to make sure businesses were complying with the law so it can be done.

Those type of inspections – along with a centralised asbestos database – is what the industry is lacking.

Really we need to push towards more active removal because if we don’t remove it’s always going to be around and someone somewhere will always be ignorant of the rules, choose to ignore them or do something stupid and they will end up damaging asbestos.

The only way to remove the risk completely is to remove asbestos so it’s something we need to look at.

However, in the meantime it’s important that we all take asbestos management seriously in our workplaces, homes, schools and public buildings.

To protect yourselves and others make sure the buildings you are in have an asbestos survey so you can identify if there is asbestos, where it is, what type it is and what condition it is in.

This is the first step to making sure everyone is kept safe and no one is prosecuted for breaching the law.

If you’re reading this and you don’t know where to start then have a conversation with us. We would rather have 100 conversations and get no work from them but know that have people have gone away more educated and aren’t going to be at risk anymore.

Acorn is a professional asbestos consultancy helping organisations deal with asbestos compliance using asbestos surveysasbestos air testing, and asbestos removal management. Please call one of the team, or use the online form to obtain your free quotation. If you would like further information or advice on asbestos and asbestos training, contact the team on 0844 818 0895 or Contact Us   

Ian Stone

I am based out of our Northampton office but regularly travel to meet with new and existing clients. I have assisted thousands of clients over the years on varying-sized projects, several have been schemes totalling over one million pounds spent purely on asbestos. Together with Neil Munro, I host our weekly podcast – Asbestos Knowledge Empire and I am Co-author of Asbestos The Dark Arts and Fear and Loathing of Health and Safety.

Need Help? Request a Call Back

Request a call back from one of our expert Asbestos Consultants who will help you identify what you need

More Asbestos Articles

Asbestos Sample Testing 1

Unusual Uses of Asbestos

Although widely acknowledged as a hazardous building material, there has been a multitude of unusual uses of asbestos throughout its history. Some may have practical foundations, whereas others seem more sublime. This article explores the variety of uses of asbestos throughout the centuries. Beauty Asbestos has previously been used in several health and beauty products … Read more

mesothelioma image

The Potential Lethality of Asbestos

The Potential Lethality of Asbestos. Asbestos is a hazardous material that has a rich history in the UK. It was used regularly in buildings between the 1950s and the late 1990s. Asbestos that is well maintained, not disturbed or damaged is much less of a risk to health. The HSE (Health and Safety Executive) reports that … Read more

IMG 0639

What you need to know about Asbestos & CLASP Buildings

Are you aware of the risk relating to Asbestos & CLASP Buildings? CLASP (which stands for Consortium of Local Authorities Special Programme) system was a scheme developed in the 1950s through to the 1980s, by English local authorities to devise a method of designing and assembling prefabricated buildings for use in the public sector. CLASP … Read more

DSCF0564 e1431533668372

Acorn Launch New Asbestos Testing Laboratory

We’re pleased to announce the launch of our new asbestos sample testing laboratory. With an extension to scope on our UKAS accreditation we now have a fully operational asbestos laboratory in Northampton (See our location). The purpose fitted laboratory has two asbestos bulk analysis stations with room for two further stations in the future. Our … Read more

school

Asbestos Excluded From Schools Surveys

The Education Funding Agency has recent published the result of the Property Data Survey Programme. A schools survey programme where asbestos was excluded from the information collected. This schools survey programme consisted of a series of high-level surveys of educational establishments in England. The schools surveys were to provide detailed information on the condition of the … Read more

asbestos through a scope

Should you be concerned about asbestos?

Blunt question – Should you bother with asbestos or be concerned about asbestos? Asbestos is an emotive word, it brings some people out in cold sweats and other say it’s all a load of fuss about nothing.  Regardless of your current opinion let’s look at whether you should deal with any asbestos issues you may … Read more

mesothelioma image

Increase in Mesothelioma deaths

The Health and Safety Executive has just published the mesothelioma statistics for 2012.  These are the latest figures relating to this disease. The numbers have significantly increased from the previous published figures, showing an increase in Mesothelioma deaths.   Mesothelioma used to be a relatively rare cancer. In this disease, malignant cells develop in the … Read more

DSCF0017

Asbestos Compliance in Schools

Asbestos Compliance In Schools – HSE have released their latest findings This latest asbestos project undertaken by the HSE was a programme aimed at assessing asbestos compliance in schools.  The assessment was questionnaire based and was specifically designed to collect information regarding compliance with The Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012. The schools assessed were independent or … Read more

An asbestos refurbishment survey in action in Northampton

Asbestos Survey Reports

Do you know what should be in an asbestos survey report? In this article I will outline what information should be provided if the survey has been carried out in line with the HSE guidance document HSG 264. Whilst it is not a legal requirement to have an asbestos survey carried out, it is a … Read more

which asbestos survey

Which Asbestos Survey Do I Need?

Navigating the complexities of asbestos management is a critical responsibility for property managers. From identifying the right asbestos survey to selecting a proficient surveyor, our guide provides a comprehensive roadmap. Learn about the three primary types of asbestos surveys – management, refurbishment, and demolition – and understand how to respond effectively if you suspect the presence of asbestos in your building. Partner with experts like Acorn Analytical Services to ensure safety and compliance at every step.