Asbestos management inquiry held by Government

The Government’s Work and Pensions Committee has been carrying out an inquiry into the HSE's approach to asbestos management

Over the past few months, the Government’s Work and Pensions Committee has been carrying out an inquiry into the approach of the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) to asbestos management in buildings.

There are six million tonnes of asbestos in the UK, most of which can be found in more than 1.5 million buildings across our public estate, including our hospitals and schools. This means many people are still exposed to the potential dangers of asbestos on a daily basis.

Consequently, despite a complete ban on the use of asbestos in 1999, the UK’s hidden legacy of asbestos means the dangerous substance remains the UK’s largest single cause of work-related deaths.

More than 5,000 people die every year from diseases linked to asbestos, including mesothelioma, lung cancer and asbestosis.

Why is the HSE’s approach to asbestos management being looked at now?

The Committee first raised concerns about the UK’s policy on asbestos management with the Government in 2020 following a report by the independent think tank Respublica.

The report concluded that while attempts to manage asbestos’ potential harm have been made, there remained clear and present dangers to the population from asbestos in-situ.

It said due to the sheer volume of asbestos in our built environment the task of managing this material demands a strong response from government but it found this to be ‘absent in the current health and safety regime’.

Respublica said understanding the true scale of the problem is difficult because there is no central database that identifies which buildings contain which type of asbestos, where – within these structures – asbestos is present, and what condition it is in.

It highlighted the current health and safety regime is based on the assumption that asbestos is safe unless disturbed. Asbestos management in-situ, rather than systematic phased removal, is therefore the preferred policy position, with responsibility falling on individual ‘duty holders’ to ensure health and safety regulations are complied with.

It added where asbestos in-situ is disturbed, there is a requirement to monitor for asbestos fibres released into the air. However, it found the UK’s air monitoring standards fall below those of other European countries, whose testing methods are up to one hundred times more sensitive in detecting dangerous airborne particles.

What is the Government hoping to learn about the HSE’s approach to asbestos management?

After the Committee raised its concerns about the UK’s asbestos management policy, the Minister for Employment confirmed the HSE would be reviewing the effectiveness of the regulations for managing asbestos.

The Committee’s inquiry is examining the current risks posed by asbestos in the workplace, the actions taken by the HSE to mitigate them and how the UK’s approach compares to those taken in other countries.

So far, the Committee has held three sessions where it has invited leading experts to give evidence.

It began by interviewing safety campaigners, representatives from charities and support groups and French, German and Dutch experts in asbestos management.

It later interviewed epidemiologists, occupational hygiene experts and representatives from the Institution of Occupational Safety and Health and from asbestos industry associations such as the UK Asbestos Training Association (UKATA).

In the past few days, it held its final session where it interviewed the Minister of State for Disabled People, Work and Health Chloe Smith MP as well as the HSE’s chief executive and chief scientific officer.

The results of the inquiry will feed into the executive’s review and have yet to be published.

What can we do to improve asbestos management?

At Acorn we’re delighted this inquiry is taking place because despite the introduction of the Control of Asbestos at Work Regulations 2002 very little has changed in people’s attitudes towards asbestos in the past two decades.

As a result, some companies do a good job of managing their asbestos but week in week out we see the same issues we were seeing in 2002.

We still go to premises that have never had an asbestos management survey and don’t have an asbestos register – it’s as if they’re unaware of the past 20 years.

Environmental health officers go to premises for things like cleanliness and give premises hygiene ratings and we believe the same thing should happen with asbestos. There should be health and safety ratings for asbestos for businesses.

We’ve seen the HSE can do it. During Covid-19 they did lots of unannounced visits to premises to make sure businesses were complying with the law so it can be done.

Those type of inspections – along with a centralised asbestos database – is what the industry is lacking.

Really we need to push towards more active removal because if we don’t remove it’s always going to be around and someone somewhere will always be ignorant of the rules, choose to ignore them or do something stupid and they will end up damaging asbestos.

The only way to remove the risk completely is to remove asbestos so it’s something we need to look at.

However, in the meantime it’s important that we all take asbestos management seriously in our workplaces, homes, schools and public buildings.

To protect yourselves and others make sure the buildings you are in have an asbestos survey so you can identify if there is asbestos, where it is, what type it is and what condition it is in.

This is the first step to making sure everyone is kept safe and no one is prosecuted for breaching the law.

If you’re reading this and you don’t know where to start then have a conversation with us. We would rather have 100 conversations and get no work from them but know that have people have gone away more educated and aren’t going to be at risk anymore.

Acorn is a professional asbestos consultancy helping organisations deal with asbestos compliance using asbestos surveysasbestos air testing, and asbestos removal management. Please call one of the team, or use the online form to obtain your free quotation. If you would like further information or advice on asbestos and asbestos training, contact the team on 0844 818 0895 or Contact Us   

Ian Stone

I am based out of our Northampton office but regularly travel to meet with new and existing clients. I have assisted thousands of clients over the years on varying-sized projects, several have been schemes totalling over one million pounds spent purely on asbestos. Together with Neil Munro, I host our weekly podcast – Asbestos Knowledge Empire and I am Co-author of Asbestos The Dark Arts and Fear and Loathing of Health and Safety.

Need Help? Request a Call Back

Request a call back from one of our expert Asbestos Consultants who will help you identify what you need

More Asbestos Articles

England star Stuart Pearce has helped to raise awareness of mesothelioma

Mesothelioma: How an England footballer is bringing home the dangers of this hidden killer

THIS afternoon, England’s Three Lions made a winning start to their World Cup campaign beating Iran in their first match in Qatar. But one footballing legend fears he could be in danger of developing mesothelioma after starting his career as an electrician in the 1980s. While former England legend Stuart Pearce is now undoubtedly best … Read more

Viviana, one of the newest members of Acorn's team

Team talk: Meet Viviana one of the talented new recruits at Acorn Analytical Services

WITH the UK in the grip of an asbestos epidemic, recruiting talented, experienced staff to join the award-winning team of experts at Acorn Analytical Services has never been more important. Despite being banned in new buildings more than 20 years ago, asbestos remains a huge problem for many businesses and, as a result, demand for … Read more

It's time to learn your asbestos ABC

Asbestos: How learning your ABC could help us to save lives

At Acorn Analytical Services we have one very simple message – ABC – or Asbestos Before Construction. It’s a simple message but it’s also an important one. Before carrying out building work of any kind you must check for the presence of asbestos first. Not doing so could have potentially serious implications for the health … Read more

Our Movember heroes, Lewis, Dave and Dan

Meet Dave, Dan and Lewis – Acorn’s amazing Movember heroes

AS we start November, Acorn Analytical Services is very proud to be supporting Movember, the annual charity event which shines a spotlight on men’s health, in particular, mental health and suicide prevention, prostate cancer and testicular cancer. We pride ourselves on being at the heart of our community and we always try to give back … Read more

Asbestos management company is growing

Acorn Analytical Services: An ambitious asbestos management company which continues to grow

FROM small acorns strong businesses grow – something that everyone at Acorn Analytical Services is extremely proud of. Even in turbulent times, Acorn Analytical Services continues to lead the way, offering reliable asbestos management services to a wide range of businesses and organisations – from well-known high street brands to local schools and colleges. In … Read more

Asbestos training

Asbestos training: Acorn Analytical Services launches free session to build knowledge among architects

ASBESTOS has once again dominated the headlines this week reaffirming our worst fears that the UK is in the grip of an asbestos epidemic. Many older buildings, including factories, schools and hospitals, contain this dangerous material which over time is starting to degrade. It’s a ticking timebomb and, as one of the UK’s leading consultancies, … Read more

Mesothelioma dangers in the classroom

Mesothelioma: We must protect our teachers from any hidden dangers

BEHIND every statistic we read about mesothelioma there lies a story – the story of another life lost from prolonged exposure to asbestos. Sadly, over the years it’s a story that has become all too familiar. Despite being banned in the UK more than 20 years ago, asbestos is still all around us – in … Read more

Asbestos industry turbulence: Acorn remains strong

Asbestos industry turbulence: Acorn Analytical Services is strong, dynamic and well-placed to weather the storm

WHILE economic uncertainty may be starting to bite in the asbestos industry, Acorn Analytical Services continues to go from strength to strength offering essential support to clients right across the UK. With more than 20 years’ experience in the asbestos and health and safety industry, we’ve become a trusted partner to a growing number of … Read more

Mesothelioma day 2022

Mesothelioma Day: Shining a light on the work of Mesothelioma UK

TODAY, September 26, marks Mesothelioma Day in the US, an important day to raise awareness of the disease and of the dangers of asbestos worldwide. Even though asbestos was banned from new buildings in the UK more than 20 years ago, it is a problem we all still live with. Many buildings, including factories, schools … Read more

Behind the scenes of our laboratories

The science bit: Putting the important work of our laboratories under the microscope

AMONG the experts at Acorn Analytical Services is a dedicated team of laboratory analysts who work in our in-house laboratories in Northampton and Cleckheaton. Their work involves supporting our consultants, and our clients, by analysing samples of materials which are found on-site or sent to us to be investigated. Here we take a more detailed … Read more