Asbestos containing materials: Should they be eradicated or left in place?

Asbestos containing materials

Asbestos in residential and non-domestic buildings has been a major health concern for many decades, and questions have been asked as to why asbestos containing materials (ACMs) cannot be removed en masse.

Asbestos was widely used in the construction industry until its UK ban in 1999, with asbestos containing materials providing insulation and protection from fire, but they left a legacy of life-threatening illness for many who were exposed to the fibres and dust.

The long latency period of asbestos disease means symptoms don’t typically manifest until several decades after the initial exposure. Health and Safety Executive (HSE) figures show 2,595 deaths occurred from asbestos-related cancer, mesothelioma, in 2016¹ with figures not expected to decline until the end of the decade.

So how is the issue of asbestos currently dealt with in this country?

Asbestos containing materials in the UK – what is the official policy?

Current government policy is to leave asbestos in place as long as the materials encasing it are not degrading or damaged, as opposed to removing it completely from a building. This strategy has invited criticism from various quarters, however, particularly from those campaigning for action to be taken in relation to the high levels of asbestos in schools.

At face value, eradicating asbestos appears to be the natural solution to a dangerous problem. A national strategy of asbestos eradication would remove the ongoing risk of exposure that we currently face, but there are other aspects that would need evaluation.

Managing asbestos vs removing it

Here are just a few issues to consider about removing asbestos containing materials:

  • The need to close down buildings whilst asbestos removal takes place

Hospital ward closures would pose a particularly difficult logistical problem to solve given the current wait for beds in many hospitals.

  • Asbestos containing materials may form part of the structure of a building

In this case, removal may not be possible without demolishing all or part of the building.

  • Asbestos removal can be a costly process

A national eradication programme would be costly – this issue should also be measured against the current risk and the long-term health cost of leaving asbestos in place, however.

  • The risk of exposure for asbestos contractors

Accidents happen, and with a wide scale programme of asbestos removal, the risk of exposure is increased, particularly for the contractors involved but also for those working or living nearby.

  • A low level of asbestos fibres and dust would remain for a while

After asbestos containing materials have been removed low levels of dust and fibres can remain for several months, causing potential harm or preventing use of the building during this time.

Clearly, there isn’t a straightforward or easy answer to the asbestos problem. Asbestos containing materials can be found in so many areas within our older buildings, posing varying degrees of risk.

If you would like more information on dealing with asbestos, our highly experienced consultants can help. Acorn Analytical Services is a well-established and reliable consultancy offering a range of services including asbestos surveys, asbestos testing, repair and encapsulation of asbestos containing materials, and project management. Please contact one of our expert team to find out more.

Neil Munro

I work in a dual role at Acorn Analytical Services focused primarily on growing and leading the business from our Northampton office base. My focus is on overseeing all sales, marketing and financial activities from Northampton. I assist clients with high-level asbestos management strategies and training. Together with Ian Stone I host our weekly podcast – Asbestos Knowledge Empire and I'm Co-author of Asbestos The Dark Arts and Fear and Loathing of Health and Safety.

Need Help? Request a Call Back

Request a call back from one of our expert Asbestos Consultants who will help you identify what you need

More Asbestos Articles

asbestos in fire

Asbestos and Fire – What Are The Risks?

Asbestos is something which is a major health risk and can cause serious damage to the lungs and the respiratory system following exposure. However, asbestos and fire can make the material pose be a greater risk when damaged in this way. In order to try and help with this, we’re taking a look at some … Read more

Acorn Lower Service 32

What should the recent death of a lady with asbestos-linked cancer teach us about asbestos?

Last year, a Northampton woman died after a short battle with cancer that could have been caused by asbestos. It was an out-of-the-blue illness that was sudden – but could it have been due to asbestos exposure at home or workplace? Asbestos has serious risks Forget what you think you know about asbestos. It’s a … Read more

An asbestos refurbishment survey in action in Northampton

The importance of an asbestos refurbishment survey

Asbestos has been dubbed as a “silent killer” for years now, although it’s an unfortunate fact that it kills more people every year – through asbestos fibres being inhaled – than people who are in road traffic accidents. It has been banned in Britain since 1999, which means any house built or refurbished prior to … Read more

IMG 0527 Small

Asbestos Causing Delays

Asbestos causing delays once again. The A21 is a busy road linking Hastings, Tunbridge Wells and south east London. Works are currently being carried out on a 2.5 mile stretch to widen the road and improve routes to the coast. Bottlenecks were a regular occurrence close to Pembury and campaigners worked for years to get … Read more

What does asbestos look like

BBC Breakfast Interview Mesothelioma Patient, Trevor Barlow

On the morning of the 20th November 2015, BBC Breakfast News published the story of Trevor Barlow a 71 year old gentleman who had been diagnosed with terminal illness due to exposure to asbestos. The interview has encouraged others to consider the effects of exposure to asbestos and highlights the current government plans to assist … Read more

Acorn Analytical Services Asbestos Solutions commecial photography 150x150 1

Asbestos Priority Risk Assessment

Recognising the potential dangers of asbestos, leads owners to responsibly address any potential concerns about the building products used in the construction of their properties. Regulation 4 Duty to manage asbestos in non-domestic premises (CAR2012) requires dutyholders to ensure that “the risk of anyone being exposed to these materials is assessed”. This type of risk assessment is … Read more

Asbestos Sample Testing 1

Unusual Uses of Asbestos

Although widely acknowledged as a hazardous building material, there has been a multitude of unusual uses of asbestos throughout its history. Some may have practical foundations, whereas others seem more sublime. This article explores the variety of uses of asbestos throughout the centuries. Beauty Asbestos has previously been used in several health and beauty products … Read more

mesothelioma image

The Potential Lethality of Asbestos

The Potential Lethality of Asbestos. Asbestos is a hazardous material that has a rich history in the UK. It was used regularly in buildings between the 1950s and the late 1990s. Asbestos that is well maintained, not disturbed or damaged is much less of a risk to health. The HSE (Health and Safety Executive) reports that … Read more

IMG 0639

What you need to know about Asbestos & CLASP Buildings

Are you aware of the risk relating to Asbestos & CLASP Buildings? CLASP (which stands for Consortium of Local Authorities Special Programme) system was a scheme developed in the 1950s through to the 1980s, by English local authorities to devise a method of designing and assembling prefabricated buildings for use in the public sector. CLASP … Read more

DSCF0564 e1431533668372

Acorn Launch New Asbestos Testing Laboratory

We’re pleased to announce the launch of our new asbestos sample testing laboratory. With an extension to scope on our UKAS accreditation we now have a fully operational asbestos laboratory in Northampton (See our location). The purpose fitted laboratory has two asbestos bulk analysis stations with room for two further stations in the future. Our … Read more